5 Best Northern Pike Lures of 2023

Photo of author
Last Updated:

Northern pikes are sharp hunters known for their big size, agility, and aggressiveness. The aggressiveness of the northern pike coupled with their acrobatic leaps makes them a prize game for anglers.

The thrill that comes with northern pike fishing is truly exciting, making it a worthwhile experience for every angler. For northern pike anglers, using the right pike lures is important for a successful pike fishing outing.

We have put together a list of five of the best northern pike lures of 2023 for you to choose from.

An 8.3lb / 3.7kg pike caught and safely released in Ireland

Best Northern Pike Lures

The five best northern pike fishing lures for anglers are:

  1. Spoon – Johnson Silver Minnow
  2. Spinner Bait – Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait 
  3. Crank Bait – Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait 
  4. Jerk Bait – Rapala Husky Jerk
  5. Buzz Bait – D&M Custom Slow Roller Buzzbait

1. Spoon

Spoons are the go-to choice for many anglers when it comes to northern pike fishing. This is due to the simplicity of this lure as well as its effectiveness. A spoon refers to a curved piece of metal that has a hook. The vibration and flash of spoons make them function as a lure for the northern pike.

A spoon is usually tough, ensuring durability and sturdiness. These qualities stand spoons out as a reliable lure, which every angler should have in their tackle box. 

Best Choice: Johnson Silver Minnow

The Johnson Silver Minnow spoon combines simplicity and effectiveness, allowing anglers to fish without stress. A rigid weedless spoon, the Johnson Silver Minnow is dependable for luring northern pike from a weed bed.

You do not have to worry about your spoon catching onto weed with the Johnson Silver Minnow. You can cast out your spoon and reel it back in seamlessly. It also provides you with wobbling action to lure the pike.

The Johnson Silver Minnow comes in different colors, which include gold, silver as well as red, and white. The silver and red, and white variants work best for sunny days, while gold should be used on cloudy days. 

Other spoons to consider are Doctor Spoon and Eppinger Dardevle.

2. Spinnerbait

If you are fishing in a body of water with heavy vegetation, you might want to consider a spinnerbait. Spinnerbaits are designed with a teardrop blade which keeps the lure from getting caught on weed.

The way it works, a spinnerbait creates a vibration by skimming over the vegetation, which doubles as the strike zone. This will attract the northern pike and cause it to strike, thereby enabling you to catch it in the process.  

Best Choice: Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait 

The Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait is a reliable tool for fishing northern pike. It is strong enough to withstand the sharp teeth of pike, having a sturdy Vibra-Fix wireframe. It also comes with a 12-inch steel leader, which ensures that the northern pike cannot bite through your fishing line.

A Silo-Tex skirt simulates the action of injured prey. The double willow blades of the Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait create vibration and flash in the water. These two features combine to lure the pike to the bait. 

Other spinnerbaits to consider are Mepps Musky Killer Spinner. 

3. Crank Bait

This northern pike fishing lure is suited for deeper water and can be divided into lipless crank baits and deep divers. The lipless crank bait is suitable for pike fishing, as the motion of the lure is enough to drive fish crazy. In deep water, a lipless crank bait can reach about 12 feet. 

Best Choice: Rapala Super Shad Rap

The Rapala Super Shad Rap is an excellent choice of lure for pike anglers fishing on a big body of water. A big lure that measures 5.5 inches, it is suitable for catching big pikes. To lure the pike, the Rapala Super Shad Rap comes in an attractive perch design.

It also moves like an injured prey to give off vibrations that will pique the northern pike’s sensitive literal line. The Rapala Super Shad Rap can be used for trolling as well as casting. 

4. Jerk Bait

Jerk bait is very similar to crankbait in the sense that they send vibrations to the northern pike using their movement. Jerk bait typically moves in a stop-and-go motion luring the pike to think that it is prey.

Best Choice: Rapala Husky Jerk

The Rapala Husky Jerk is a large bait that attracts northern pike using aggressive movement. After it is cast out, it is then retrieved in sharp motion, which causes aggressive twitches. This movement causes vibrations in the water, thereby attracting the attention of the northern pike.

5. Buzz Bait

Just as the name suggests, buzz bait is a type of lure that attracts northern pike by using buzz. This buzz refers to a combination of sound and light (flash). 

Best Choice: D&M Custom Slow Roller Buzzbait

The D&M Custom Slow Roller Buzzbait serves as an effective lure for northern pike in the strike zone. With its slow retrieval, you can keep it on the water long enough to attract a big northern pike. The soft tone and flashy color also help to attract the pike.

Spinning for predatory pike

Things to Consider When Buying a Lure for Northern Pike

Pike Teeth

Northern pikes have strong and sharp, which gives them a tight grip on their prey and anything else that they bite. As a matter of fact, most pikes have sharp fang-like rows of teeth that number between 300 and 700.

Owing to the number and strength of their teeth, pike can easily bite through your fishing line and destroy any lure that you throw in the water. This is why a leader should be an important part of your tackle box. A leader will help you to prevent the pike from biting off your lure.  

Pike Senses

Pike have physical features which make it easy for them to lay ambush for their prey. With a sensitive literal line, they can sense vibrations, buzz, flashes, buzz, rattles, or even flutters of approaching or injured prey.

This sense helps them to locate their prey swiftly. They also enjoy the low-light vision and impressive depth perception, which enables them to fish in the dark, usually at dusk and dawn. As a result of their hunting style, it is best to go northern pike fishing around sunset and sunrise.

This is because they are most active at this time. Northern pike lures with bright colors are great for alerting the senses of the pike. Vibration, buzz, and flash are other factors to consider when choosing a fishing lure.

Pike Behavior

Northern pikes are expert hunters that make use of aquatic weeds as camouflage to catch their prey off guard. As such, you will be sure to find them in parts of the water with a weed bed.

Northern pike feeds on a variety of animals, including mice, bats, snakes, frogs, and different kinds of fish. This makes fishing lures a good option for northern pike fishing. Fishing lures that are colorful will catch the attention of northern pike faster.


Whatever pike lure you choose, it is important to know that pike fishing requires precision. Ensure to get a leader in order to provide the pike from biting through your fishing line. Also, be sure to use lures that are flashy enough to stimulate the senses of the pike.

Vibrations and buzzes also help stimulate pike. Remember that pikes are aggressive, so you must be ready to match their strength. Check the area where you are fishing to be sure it has vegetation.

Plan your fishing time to sunset or sunrise, as pike usually hunts around this period. Overall, it is important to go with complete gear in order to guarantee your safety. 

Daniel O’Neill
Fishing Expert
Meet Daniel, an avid writer and fanatic angler with a deep love for fishing. As a fly fishing guide and instructor, Daniel brings a wealth of expertise to his writing. With a degree in Business Information Technology, his analytical mindset enhances his understanding of the sport. Daniel's fishing ventures have yielded impressive results, including memorable catches like mullet, sturgeon, double-figure pike and atlantic salmon. In Ireland, he excels as a spearo, specializing in targeting pollock and bass. As a writer for Cast & Spear, Daniel combines his firsthand knowledge, educational background, and unwavering passion to create engaging content. His articles provide valuable insights, tips, and techniques, empowering readers to elevate their fishing skills and embark on thrilling angling adventures.
× How can we improve it?
× Thanks for your feedback!

We're always looking to improve our articles to help you become an even better fisherman.

While you're here, why not follow us on Facebook and YouTube? Facebook YouTube

7 Best Pike Baits: A Comprehensive Guide for Anglers

Are you unsure of which pike baits will work for your waters? Our article focuses on pike baits, including scented attractants and pike hunting styles. Discover valuable insights on how you can improve your catch rate. In this article, predator hunter Daniel O’Neill, who has caught over sixty double-figure pike, discusses the best pike baits
fishing hook in finger

What to Do When a Fishing Hook Gets Stuck in Your Finger

To remove a fishing hook stuck in a finger, cut the fishing line, lure, or bait from the hook to remove the fishing hook in the finger. Next, apply ice on the affected area to numb the nerves. If the hook has not penetrated through the skin, gently pull the tip of your hook. If
northern pike teeth

Northern Pike Teeth: Everything You Need to Know

Northern pikes are natural predators whose teeth are razor-sharp, designed to slice and dice their prey. The teeth multiply as the pike grows. How many teeth a pike has depends on the age and size, but generally, a fully grown pike can have up to 700 teeth. Additionally, the length of their teeth depends on
Best Saltwater Fishing Lures

7 Best Saltwater Fishing Lures for Monster Fish

The lures we’re going to cover today are so effective they should be BANNED! But we’ll keep that secret between you and me. We’ve asked hundreds of fishermen what lures they recommended that most people don’t know about. Below is a list of their top picks. Make sure you add them to your arsenal! Listen
white sea bass

How To Catch White Seabass

According to Captain Mark Winch, you’ll want to try a few different approaches to catch white seabass. The Short Answer The first is slow trolling a large mackerel on a Carolina rig using a 4-ounce egg sinker, 40-pound fluorocarbon, to a #1 or #2 treble hook. If the squid is around, you can fly line
how to fish with frog

How to Fish for Bass with Frog Baits

A giant largemouth blowing up on a topwater frog is undoubtedly the most thrilling method for catching bass. Bass frog fishing gives an exciting, quick-paced opportunity for sight fishing that will test your patience. In some cases, it might even be the most efficient way of catching bass. You need to understand more about frog